Our scale
5.0 — Exceptional
A standout work with very few meaningful weaknesses.
4.0–4.5 — Very good
A strong recommendation with clear strengths that outweigh its flaws.
3.0–3.5 — Good with limitations
A worthwhile experience whose weaknesses are significant enough to mention.
2.0–2.5 — Mixed
Some worthwhile elements, but substantial problems limit the experience.
1.0–1.5 — Poor
Major problems prevent the work from delivering a satisfying experience.
Important
A rating is only published when there is genuine editorial basis for assigning one. Research alone is not treated as a substitute for watching or experiencing the work.